Pumpkin beer seems to be everywhere and with the season fading fast, I wanted to review at least one before they left stores and made way for the beers of winter. As luck would have it the 21st Amendment Brewery and Elysian Brewing collaborated on brewing 2 different styles of pumpkin beer and packaged them together(talk about a 2 for 1). He Said Belgian Tripel and He Said Baltic Porter offer 2 unique takes on the pumpkin beer. As excited as I am to try these beers, my expectations are tempered because I find that pumpkin beer is commonly hit or miss. Some of the time you will find a beer that captures the unique flavor of pumpkin and complements to the fall season wonderfully. Other times you will find a mediocre beer that is heavily spiced to a point you can taste little else. Needless to say I was curious to see which side of the coin the He Said Porter and He Said Tripel would land on.
He Said Tripel pours a clear golden yellow with a white head. The aroma is filled with clove, coriander, pepper and pumpkin. The flavor however does not seem as complex. The initial flavor is pumpkin but it is very light and it is followed by a strong candy sweetness, then a spicy finish from the yeast. The is a slight burn from the alcohol(8.2% ABV)hat grew the further I got into the glass. While that did not bother me, the growing flavor of the Belgian spice did. It got to a point where I could no longer taste the pumpkin and felt like I was drinking nothing more then an average tripel ale. By the time the glass was empty I felt it was more of a below-average tripel and I was happy this beer drinking experience was over. I then hoped I would have more luck with the He Said Baltic Porter.
He Said Baltic Porter pours a rich black with red highlights and a khaki colored head. In the aroma I detected roasted malt, chocolate, pumpkin and nutmeg. The flavor was fairly on point with the aroma. The initial flavor is roasted malt, pumpkin, with light chocolate sweetness that finishes dry with nutmeg and ginger. And while that might sound fairly interesting, it seemed more middle of the road to me. There is really little here that you can't find in other beers. With that being said if you ordered this beer hoping try something new that fits the season then you wouldn't be disappointed.
As a whole I felt underwhelmed by the He Said 2-pack. To me, neither beer stood out and I feel like I can safely say I won't be purchasing either one again. In my opinion there are a lot better-tasting and more economical pumpkin beers on the market. But if you insist on finding a pumpkin beer with a higher ABV and more flavor I'd recommend Southern Tier Warlock.
Overall I'd rate He Said Tripel a 1.5/5 and He Said Baltic Porter a 2.5/5. I honestly can't see why either brewery would be proud of these beers. I'd expect something this boring to come from one of the mass produced American beer giants then two reliable microbreweries.
Rating Scale:
1 - Repugnant and undrinkable
2 - Acceptable but forgettable
3 - Good, worth a purchase
4 - Excellent, a step above the norm
5 - Truly exceptional
To discuss this blog or all things beer follow me on Twitter at @ACraftyLook
For more beer reviews go to: http://acraftylook.blogspot.com/
Thanks for reading. Sláinte!
